April 1, 2005
ARTICLE: Smuggled Ethiopian treasures sold on eBay
Here is my first article for the Sub Saharan Informer - published here because the paper, as yet, does not have a website.
Ebay, the world's biggest online marketplace, was this week accused of allowing the sale of smuggled Ethiopian treasures on its website.Academics said they had evidence that holy historic crosses - and at least one sacred manuscript - were being auctioned off through eBay despite an Ethiopian government ban on the export of cultural and religious antiques.
Elizabeth Giorgis, acting director of the Institute of Ethiopian Studies in Addis Ababa University, said she was writing to eBay directors to demand they block the sales. "It is totally inappropriate for a company like eBay to be selling these smuggled treasures," she added.
"They are in effect encouraging people to rob the country of its cultural heritage. They have a moral obligation to protect these objects."
Giorgis decided to speak out after being contacted by a number of Ethiopians in the US who had seen a number historical Ethiopian objects for sale on the website.
In one case, an eBay seller claimed he had tracked down a priest's gospel and a collection of silver crosses belonging to a cash-strapped family living in Ethiopia. He justified his high price for the items because of the difficulties arising from Ethiopia's export restrictions.
In the seller's description, he stated: "Due to current Ethiopian government export restrictions, no gospels or silver crosses are now allowed to be legally taken out of Ethiopia and for this reason the offering price is extremely reasonable and not nearly the premium that should be asked for such a valuable and rare Ethiopian religious relic of museum quality."
EBay currently has strict guidelines banning people from using its site to sell artefacts from the USA's Native American and Hawaiian populations. But the company has no similar guidelines relating to historic items from other cultures from outside North America.
"This is a clear case of double standards," said Giorgis. "Why go out of your way to protect items from your own country but do nothing to protect African treasures?"
She also questioned whether eBay has set up strong enough safeguards to prevent the sale of illegally smuggled goods via its servers. She urged it to follow the lead of bricks-and-mortar auctioneers like Christies or Sothebys who have to check the background of antiques before offering them to the public.
Giorgis was backed up by the Institute's Professor Richard Pankhurst, who is also vice chair of AFROMET (www.afromet.org) - an organization dedicated to retrieving hundreds of priceless treasures taken during the British invasion of Ethiopia in 1868.
"Unless they get permission to export these items, the sellers are breaking the law," said Pankhurst. "It is only because of the relative poverty of Ethiopia - and the high prices being offered for these objects, that is happening at all."
Hand-written goatskin bibles, prayer books and colourful illuminations dating as far back as the 17th century currently exchange hands for up to $3,900 a piece on the popular website. Many of the items are modern - and therefore exempt from export restrictions.
But the Sub Saharan Informer found at least one other case of a seller claiming to have bought an antique manuscript inside Ethiopia before exporting it to America.
Ebay was not avaialble to comment on this story as the Sub Saharan Informer went to press.
Posted by aheavens at April 1, 2005 11:10 AM
Comments
I thought this was an April fools day joke until I did a quick ebay search.
Posted by: Camdon at April 8, 2005 9:18 PM
Hi there, my name is Renee i'm a Journalism student at the United States International university and i was woundering if you are a journalist and if so what is your opinion of the way the media operates in Eastern Africa or Uganda.
Posted by: renee at October 7, 2005 8:59 AM
I can't believe it, my co-worker just bought a car for $47363. Isn't that crazy!
Posted by: Betsy Markum at January 10, 2006 12:33 AM
Why would Germany and all these other countries be so obsesed about obtaining ancient Ethiopian artifacts when for so many years they have tried to convince us and the rest the world of their supieriority, could it be because they all really know the secrets to our true beginings of civilization and the human race are or was in Ethiopia. HMMMMMMM
Posted by: iahest at May 26, 2006 3:53 PM
I am very glad to see the comments forwarded by Elisabeth W/Giorgis from the Institute of Ethiopian Studies, Addis Ababa university about the illicit trafficking and selling of Ethiopian cultural heritage on ebay. According to the Ethiopian law exporting and selling of cultural heritage such as rare hand written manuscripts, anicent church crosses and other cultural objects that have cultural, artistic and scientific values are not allowed either for sell or for export outside the country. plese stop robbing the cultural heritage of this old nation that has contributed a lot the world including Ethiopian alphabet,coinage,calender,manuscripts at least dating to the early beginning of the first millenium AD. Aksum, the northern part of Ethiopia was the cross road of to Europe, Asia and Africa in the first century AD. In the thrid century AD, this country issued its own gold, silver and bronze coins that are on sell on this ebay. please stop selling our heritages which are our identity. Stop encoraging the illicit traffiking of cultural heritage in this country. Stop selling our cultural heritage.
Posted by: tekle at June 24, 2008 12:44 PM